Totally Lost MTG Card

Card Pros

Card Advantage: Totally Lost is a unique blue spell that removes any nonland permanent from the battlefield and puts it on top of its owner’s library. This action can temporarily clear the path for your attacks or disrupt your opponent’s strategy, effectively causing them to lose a draw since they would draw into the same card again.

Resource Acceleration: Although Totally Lost doesn’t produce mana or Treasure tokens directly, the ability to upend carefully-laid plans can slow down an opponent’s resource progression, giving you an implicit speed advantage. By delaying their board development, you can accelerate your own strategy without opposition.

Instant Speed: The power of instant speed spells lies in their flexibility, and Totally Lost is no exception. This card can be cast during your opponent’s turn, allowing you to respond to threats in a timely manner or simply cast it when it would be most inconvenient for your adversary, right before they draw.

Card Cons

Discard Requirement: One key drawback of Totally Lost is that it does not require a discard, so while you won’t lose additional cards from your hand, it lacks the potential synergy with graveyard strategies or cards that benefit from discarding.

Specific Mana Cost: With its specific cost of four colorless and one blue mana, Totally Lost is tailored for decks that can reliably produce blue mana and may not fit comfortably into multi-color decks not focused on blue.

Comparatively High Mana Cost: The five mana investment to simply bounce a creature or nonland permanent can be a setback, especially when there are cards with lower mana costs that provide similar or even more versatile effects. This may lead players to opt for those alternatives in deck construction.

Reasons to Include Totally Lost in Your Collection

Versatility: Totally Lost is adaptable to multiple situations in a game. It can interrupt your opponent’s strategies by removing their key creature from combat, or resetting a permanent with a beneficial entered-the-battlefield effect to use again.

Combo Potential: This card has synergy within decks built around instant-speed interactions, providing you with the opportunity to disrupt your adversaries during their most crucial plays or at the end of their turn for maximum efficiency.

Meta-Relevance: In environments where formidable creatures or permanents dominate, Totally Lost serves as a timely answer to those threats, aligning well with control-oriented decks seeking to buy time and maintain a stable board state.

How to beat

Totally Lost, the whimsical yet disruptive spell, has floated into the decks of many players who relish in confounding their opponents. Its ability to put a nonland permanent on top of its owner’s library can throw off an opponent’s strategy, especially when dealing with a menacing threat that’s hard to handle. To effectively sideline Totally Lost, consider using instant-speed spells that can counter it or cards that can shuffle your library, diluting the effect of being set back by a card.

Direct removal spells, such as Murder, can effectively eliminate the targeted creature before Totally Lost resolves. In this case, the spell would lose its target and essentially fizzle out. Furthermore, implementing strategies that involve frequent shuffling of your library, like fetch lands or effects from cards like Rampant Growth, would minimize the impact of your opponent’s attempt at disrupting the top of your library. Adapt your play to include these strategies, and you’ll find Totally Lost becoming far less of a setback in your matches.