Which of You Burns Brightest? MTG Card


Which of You Burns Brightest? - Archenemy Schemes
RarityCommon
TypeScheme
Released2010-06-18
Set symbol
Set nameArchenemy Schemes
Set codeOARC
Number42★
Frame2003
LayoutScheme
BorderBlack
Illustred bySteve Prescott

Key Takeaways

  1. Draw three cards with this enchanting saga, ramping up game tempo amidst fierce competition.
  2. Demands strategic hand management due to its discard requirement for spell initiation.
  3. Highly flexible, it becomes increasingly potent with a growing collection of instant and sorcery spells.

Text of card

When you set this scheme in motion, you may pay . If you do, this scheme deals X damage to target opponent and each creature he or she controls.

"Let that be a lesson to you, your family, and everyone you've ever known."


Card Pros

Card Advantage: “Which of You Burns Brightest?” shines by allowing you to draw three cards when played, outpacing many other spells in the same mana range. This influx of new options can keep your hand fueled and pressure high on your opponents.

Resource Acceleration: As an enchanting saga, this card not only offers card draw but puts you ahead by representing a ticking time bomb for your opponents. By demanding answers or accelerating towards your impactful late-game spells, it’s a compelling choice for strategies that thrive on maintaining a sustained pace of play.

Instant Speed: While this card itself may not be an instant, it synergizes seamlessly with instant-speed spells in your arsenal. The third lore counter’s ability can be a game-changer, turning an end-of-turn instant into a devastating play that can swing the game in your favor right when your adversary least expects it.


Card Cons

Discard Requirement: Which of You Burns Brightest asks you to discard a card to initiate its effect. This can pose a strategic disadvantage, especially if your hand is scarce or if the cards you hold are critical for maintaining your game plan.

Specific Mana Cost: This card requires a specific combination of mana to cast. It demands both red mana and an additional cost, potentially restricting its versatility across various deck builds that may not have an abundance of these mana types.

Comparatively High Mana Cost: The card’s mana cost is significant when considering the scope of its impact. For its four-mana investment, players might find that other cards in the same mana range provide more value or fit seamlessly into the deck’s overarching strategy without the same prerequisites.


Reasons to Include in Your Collection

Versatility: Which of You Burns Brightest? offers a dynamic option for decks focused on spell casting or burn strategies. Its ability to scale in power depending on the number of instant and sorcery spells you cast makes it a threat that can adapt to various game states.

Combo Potential: With the capacity to amplify the effectiveness of damage-dealing spells, this card synergizes with setups aiming to deal copious amounts of damage in a single turn. The potential to create devastating spell combinations is a draw for players looking to concoct explosive plays.

Meta-Relevance: Considering the pace of the current gameplay, a card like Which of You Burns Brightest? can become critical in outpacing opponents in races to inflict damage. It situates itself well in an environment where tempo and immediate impacts on the board state are pivotal to securing victory.


How to beat

Which of You Burns Brightest? is a unique challenge for players in the world of Magic: The Gathering. For those seeking a path to victory against this card, understanding and agility are key. The crux of the strategy lies in suppressing the opponent’s momentum, given that the card rewards them for casting spells with higher mana costs. A savvy approach involves leveraging counter spells or removals to disrupt their game plan. Efficiently managing your mana and spell casting while tactically choosing the right moment to interfere with your opponent’s play can effectively neutralize the advantage Which of You Burns Brightest? offers.

Another tactic is to quicken your tempo—applying pressure on your opponent early in the game with creatures and low-cost spells that offer both offensive and defensive capabilities, effectively racing against their build-up of resources. The idea is to gain advantage before your competitor can fully exploit the potential of Which of You Burns Brightest? Remember, it’s not just about reacting but proactively shaping the game in your favor. Patience and timing are the secret ingredients to ensure your opponent’s brightness does not eclipse your road to triumph.


Cards like Which of You Burns Brightest?

Which of You Burns Brightest? is a dynamic card offering players a unique choice in the MTG universe. Its closest counterparts often involve cards from the “choose your own destiny” family, such as Browbeat. The distinctive feature enabling players to decide between taking damage or allowing the card’s controller to draw cards shares a thematic link. However, Which of You Burns Brightest? stands out by presenting a varied pair of choices, pushing opponents into a corner to make a tougher decision or face the consequences.

Fiery Confluence is another card inviting comparison, as it involves a set of three possible actions that a player can choose. The pivotal difference lies in the option to choose the same action more than once, which isn’t the case for Which of You Burns Brightest?. Conversely, Risk Factor brings in the instant-speed interaction and the ability to be cast again from the graveyard, offering a repeated challenge to the opponent.

Overall, Which of You Burns Brightest? carves out a niche in the decision-forcing space with its ability to direct the game’s flow uniquely. This card can pivot key moments in gameplay that are unparalleled in the MTG landscape, making it a noteworthy piece in strategic deck constructions.

Browbeat - MTG Card versions
Fiery Confluence - MTG Card versions
Risk Factor - MTG Card versions
Browbeat - MTG Card versions
Fiery Confluence - MTG Card versions
Risk Factor - MTG Card versions

Cards similar to Which of You Burns Brightest? by color, type and mana cost

Perhaps You've Met My Cohort - MTG Card versions
Imprison This Insolent Wretch - MTG Card versions
Your Inescapable Doom - MTG Card versions
All in Good Time - MTG Card versions
The Dead Shall Serve - MTG Card versions
Surrender Your Thoughts - MTG Card versions
Mortal Flesh Is Weak - MTG Card versions
The Iron Guardian Stirs - MTG Card versions
Ignite the Cloneforge! - MTG Card versions
I Bask in Your Silent Awe - MTG Card versions
Nature Demands an Offering - MTG Card versions
Look Skyward and Despair - MTG Card versions
Nothing Can Stop Me Now - MTG Card versions
Plots That Span Centuries - MTG Card versions
I Know All, I See All - MTG Card versions
Rotted Ones, Lay Siege - MTG Card versions
A Display of My Dark Power - MTG Card versions
Behold the Power of Destruction - MTG Card versions
My Genius Knows No Bounds - MTG Card versions
All Shall Smolder in My Wake - MTG Card versions
Perhaps You've Met My Cohort - MTG Card versions
Imprison This Insolent Wretch - MTG Card versions
Your Inescapable Doom - MTG Card versions
All in Good Time - MTG Card versions
The Dead Shall Serve - MTG Card versions
Surrender Your Thoughts - MTG Card versions
Mortal Flesh Is Weak - MTG Card versions
The Iron Guardian Stirs - MTG Card versions
Ignite the Cloneforge! - MTG Card versions
I Bask in Your Silent Awe - MTG Card versions
Nature Demands an Offering - MTG Card versions
Look Skyward and Despair - MTG Card versions
Nothing Can Stop Me Now - MTG Card versions
Plots That Span Centuries - MTG Card versions
I Know All, I See All - MTG Card versions
Rotted Ones, Lay Siege - MTG Card versions
A Display of My Dark Power - MTG Card versions
Behold the Power of Destruction - MTG Card versions
My Genius Knows No Bounds - MTG Card versions
All Shall Smolder in My Wake - MTG Card versions

Where to buy

If you're looking to purchase Which of You Burns Brightest? MTG card by a specific set like Archenemy Schemes, there are several reliable options to consider. One of the primary sources is your local game store, where you can often find booster packs, individual cards, and preconstructed decks from current and some past sets. They often offer the added benefit of a community where you can trade with other players.

For a broader inventory, particularly of older sets, online marketplaces like TCGPlayer, Card Kingdom and Card Market offer extensive selections and allow you to search for cards from specific sets. Larger e-commerce platforms like eBay and Amazon also have listings from various sellers, which can be a good place to look for sealed product and rare finds.

Additionally, Magic’s official site often has a store locator and retailer lists for finding Wizards of the Coast licensed products. Remember to check for authenticity and the condition of the cards when purchasing, especially from individual sellers on larger marketplaces.

Below is a list of some store websites where you can buy the Which of You Burns Brightest? and other MTG cards:

Continue exploring other sealed products in Amazon
See MTG Products

Rules and information

The reference guide for Magic: The Gathering Which of You Burns Brightest? card rulings provides official rulings, any errata issued, as well as a record of all the functional modifications that have occurred.

Date Text
2010-06-15 You choose the target opponent when the ability triggers. As the ability resolves, you choose a value for X and decide whether to pay . If you do decide to pay , it’s too late for any player to respond since the ability is already in the midst of resolving.